Friday, February 29, 2008

Philip II and Victor von Doom



In issues 551 through 553 of The Fantastic Four, the FF get a surprise visit from a future version of their oldest nemesis: Victor von Doom, aka Doctor Doom. Doom has traveled back in time on a purportedly benevolent mission: to warn the team that Reed Richards will go mad with power, and that this will have disastrous consequences for the entire planet. Under normal circumstances the FF wouldn't believe Doom for a second, but they've recently been shaken to their foundations by the events of the Marvel Universe's Civil War, in which Reed made some choices that caused most of the world to lose faith in him. They listen to what Doom has to say, more or less, and then a time portal opens and their future selves - the FF from the future Doom's timeline - show up. They want to take Doom back with them, but the present-day Reed, allowing for the possibility that what Doom says is true, decides to protect Doom. Arguments - and eventually fighting - ensue between "our" FF and their future selves: not simply because the future FF want Doom, but because they remember a version of history where they fought their future selves, and this is all part of preserving the time stream! Eventually the fighting subsides as the present-day FF learn the truth. Here's the conversation between Ben Grimm, the future Doom, Sue Richards, and the future Reed Richards.

Ben:
You guys are tryin' to keep things the way they were, but Doomsie... is trying ta change history.


Doom:
As I said. To prevent Reed's madness from destroying the future.


Sue:
Destroying it how, Victor? You say you're a man of honor... tell us the truth. What's the world like where you come from?


Doom:
...
Paradise.
It's paradise.
His dual-layer Dyson swarm provides nearly free and inexhaustible energy. Advances in medicine have greatly extended both the duration and quality of life. There hasn't been a war in over 40 years, hunger and crime are all but unknown, education is universal. Art thrives.


Reed:
There's still a lot of work to do, but --


Doom:
But humanity is safe, happy, prosperous and striving for true greatness.
And it's all Richards's fault.


Ben:
Fault? Are you out of yer blamed mind?


Doom:
That honor belongs to me! I should be the savior of humanity, not Richards. Doom!


Reed:
Now you know the truth. Doom came back to the past, intending to correct history so that the future would be the product of his hand.


Fun story, huh? Well, I sure enjoyed it. But it's not just a story.


In 1571 a Christian naval coalition defeated a large Ottoman force at the Battle of Lepanto. The unprecedented cooperation between Western Christian states shows how dire the Ottoman threat had become. Had the battle gone slightly differently, the Christian forces would have been enveloped by the larger Ottoman force and crushed, leaving the eastern Mediterranean and much of eastern Europe open to further encroachment. One would think that any Christian would have felt unalloyed joy at news of the victory, let alone the king of one of the main countries involved. In my experience, though, you can always count on Philip II to behave enigmatically. First, let's put Philip's Catholic faith into perspective. The following is from page 27 of David Howarth's The Voyage of the Armada: The Spanish Story.
But it was not only a political empire; it was also a religious entity, and that was what made it so complex. King Philip was His Most Catholic Majesty. He believed he was appointed by god to defend the truth against infidels and heretics. The pope was Vicar of Christ: Philip, in his own eyes, was Champion of god, the equal of the pope in God's designs. In this sense, his boundaries were vague. There were people all over Europe, caught in the ebb and flow of Reformation and Counter-Reformation, whose loyalties were divided between their country and their church. In almost all of Philip's Catholic domains, Protestants had been exterminated, or pushed far under ground, by the Inquisition. The only exception was the Netherlands. All through his reign they had been in revolt, partly against the shame of foreign rule and partly to protect their Protestant creed: he had to keep an immensely expensive army there, and it had never succeeded in putting the rebels down. But he was not only concerned with his own domains. It was his personal duty, divinely imposed as he believed, to punish Protestants everywhere and rescue Catholics who lived under Protestant rule.
Now, on to Philip's reaction to Lepanto in 1571. The following is from page 294 of Victory of the West by Niccolo Capponi.
Despite his apparent elation over the Christian victory, the king was not totally happy about the league's success. Don Juan had put the Habsburg galleys and soldiers at considerable risk by deciding to join battle - a rash decision to say the least, especially for el rey prudente, and according to a number of Philip's councillors the prince could only thank God if he had come out of it alive. Significantly, the king commissioned only one work of art to commemorate the victory - Titian's Philip II, after the victory of Lepanto, offers the prince Don Fernando to victory, now in the Prado - and to celebrate more the continuity of the Habsburg line than the Ottoman defeat. The six large canvases of the battle by Luca Cambiaso, now in the Escorial, were probably gifts of Giovanni Andrea Doria to the royal secretary Antonio Pérez, acquired by the king at a later date. One has the distinct impression that for Philip the league victory represented a potential source of political trouble, possibly because by weakening the Porte's navy it had altered the balance of power in the Mediterranean and loosened Spain's grip on Italy.
This utterly amazed me when I first read it, and it still makes my jaw slacken a bit. Philip II was the model of a Catholic King of the sixteenth century: as relentless as he was devout. Yet upon hearing of the greatest Catholic victory of his age, his reaction was lukewarm. It didn't matter to him that Christian forces won, as long as he wasn't in control. Even if everything happened that he wanted to happen, it didn't matter as long as it wasn't by his hand. Sound familiar?

The best stories aren't just stories. They're history.

Thanks to Grace for giving me the idea for this entry. It still amazes me that I didn't think of it, seeing as how I was the one who told her about this aspect of Philip's personality.

7 comments:

Cartophiliac said...

I'm shocked! Shocked to learn that a world leader would compromise his religious principles in his quest for power. Shocked!

Seriously, throughout history, religion has rarely been the true reason for conflict. It has usually been about how nations can use religion as a means to an end... more power, more land, more money, more woemen, more resources, more bragging rights.

Still, I loved your article. I've never seen a Spanish monarch compared to Reed Richards. I enjoyed the fresh perspective.

Hugh Yeman said...

Thanks for your comment!

Regarding your statement about the ulterior motives behind wars ostensibly fought over religion, I think that for Philip II there was no such dichotomy. To me, the truly scary thing about him was that he conflated his religion and his power: God's interests were his own, so of course his hand was the only one that could enact God's purpose. Howarth gives a wonderful five-page account of Philip's character, which ends with the words "appallingly sincere". I typed it up last night and then decided that sticking five pages of text from another author into a single blog entry was a Bad Idea. If you'd like to read it, though, I'd be happy to send it along.

That ability to conflate one's own interests with God's seems to have been a pretty useful madness for a monarch. If Garrett Mattingly's take on Henry VIII in _Catherine of Aragon_ is correct, he was another one of those appallingly sincere kings. It worked out pretty well for him. The people around him... not so much.

Cartophiliac said...

Fair enough. I will concede your point.

Of late, I have been reading a lot of history about the late Roman Republic. And there, religion was so cynically used as a tool of power that I forget that many historical leaders were genuinely obsessed with religious purpose.

Hugh Yeman said...

Late Roman, huh? That's a period I've been meaning to delve into. The problem is, any period you could name aside from the sixteenth century and the New York and New Jersey campaigns of 1776 are periods I need to delve into. And those other two? I still need to delve into them *more*. So, SO much on Mt. ToBeRead, and so little concentration span.

Have you read Gibbon? That one has been eyeing me balefully.

tomatoejane said...

Yet more good stuff, Hugh. Keep it up! (that includes listening to Grace...)

Gibbon eyed me balefully for many many years until my possessions purge in the year two. I kept all the original roman writings though and never have trouble finding the will to read from them.

The inconsistencies of great men and women can often seem more jarring than the usual inconsistencies of us smaller folks. Speculating though, if Phillip thought he was God's hand in the world he might legitmately be concerned that someone else's hand might also be acting. Was that other hand acting for God, if so why hadn't God let him (Phillip) know somehow? A great faith shaker to someone so self-centered and outwardly certain of his purpose.

Anonymous said...

Who knows where to download XRumer 5.0 Palladium?
Help, please. All recommend this program to effectively advertise on the Internet, this is the best program!

Anonymous said...

La Germane to Jordan [http://www.airjordanpascherfy.com air jordan] V Passion Red, coloris White-Black-Fire Red, sortie originalement en 1990 et reedite en 2000 et 2008, fera son retour au mois de janvier [http://www.hollistersdeutschlands.com hollister] . Le meme mois sortira laAir Jordan XIII ¡®He Got Connect with together', qui a ete creee en 1997 et jamais reeditee.Un nouveau coloris de Learn of Jordan III sortira au mois de fevrier [http://www.louisevuitton.info louis vuitton pas cher] (update: coloris Black-Bright Crimson) ainsi qu'un market nouveau coloris de Sagacity Jordan XIII.
L'exterieur de la launching du magasin moderne turning de moulage blanc et noir outlook louvers.The commercialisation actuellement [http://www.hollisterberlinshop.com hollister] presente donne directement sur l'entree. L'interieur est eclaire presentable des lumieres tamisees et un eclairage de plafond endroit. Musique de danse electronique earmark a creer une heavens optimiste peut etre joue a des niveaux sonores ruffle benefit eleves que [http://www.hollistercofrance.info hollister france] 90 decibels, ce qui depasse la politique d'entreprise de 80 decibels et comparables aux machines de construction lourde et nefaste rain l'entreprise exploite 1049 magasins ears.The dans les quatre marques. La marque A & F unalloyed situated de 278 emplacements aux etats-Unis, quatre au Canada, l'un a Londres, l'un a [http://www.franklinandmarshall5fr.com franklin marshall] Dublin, l'un a Milan, l'un a Tokyo, l'un a Copenhague, l'une a D¨¹sseldorf, l'un a Munich (Octobre 2012), l'un a Madrid , celui de Barcelone, l'une a Paris, l'autre a Bruxelles, un a Hambourg (Avril 2012), une a Hong Kong (Ao?t 2012), et un dans le centre-ville d'Orchard German autobahn, Singapour
V¨ºtements prot¨¨ge les gens contre beaucoup de choses qui pourraient blesser le detachment humain d¨¦couvert. V¨ºtements agir en tant que haven folding hard cash contre les ¨¦l¨¦ments, y compris la pluie, la neige, le transmission et autres conditions m¨¦t¨¦orologiques, [http://www.abercrombiefrancesoldes.info abercrombie paris] ainsi que du soleil. Toutefois, si les v¨ºtements est trop uncomplicated, mince, petit, serr¨¦, etc, l'effet de barrier est r¨¦duite au minimum. V¨ºtements ¨¦galement de r¨¦duire le niveau de risque au cours de l'activit¨¦, comme le travail [http://www.hollisterukoutlet7s.com hollister] ou le sport. V¨ºtements parfois se porte comme une non-poisonous keeping contre certains risques environnementaux, tels que les insectes, les produits chimiques toxiques, des armes, et le association avec des substances abrasives. Inversement, les [http://www.hollisterukoutlet7s.com hollister uk] v¨ºtements peuvent prot¨¦ger l'environnement de l'utilisateur v¨ºtements, comme des m¨¦decins portant gommages m¨¦dicaux.メッ